Sunday, June 29, 2014
Valiant Hearts: The Birth of the Prestige Game
What to say about Valiant Hearts: The Great War?
It's a good game, to be sure. It manages to deftly mix moments of humor, terror, and nail-biting tension in a narrative built around a strong emotional core, buoyed by frequent "aha" moments thanks to the numerous puzzles that form the bulk of gameplay. It features some overwrought narration and an insistence on educating the player that at times can be grating. The art style is beautiful, and by adopting this style the player isn't exposed to brutal, photorealistic gore in a manner that might desensitize them to the horrific violence that marked World War I - not to mention it makes the game much more accessible.
Overall, I enjoyed my experience with the game. But throughout my playthrough I was struck by a familiar sensation. It took me a while to put my finger on it. Then it hit me.
Monday, May 26, 2014
What I Wrote in the Guestbook at Whynot? Coffee & Wine
For me, New York will probably be remembered as the city of coffee.
I didn't really touch the stuff before I started living here in earnest. Mostly I just drank tea, and I still do, but I've since graduated to its stronger, younger sibling. I've come to appreciate the taste, but it still gets me so caffeinated that I get jittery. It becomes hard for me to focus on any single thing, and I opt instead for total sensory overload.
It's a mirror for my overall experience with this city. There are always so many possibilities, so many paths before me that at times it can be downright maddening. But whenever I try to imagine living anywhere else at this point in my life, I realize how quickly I'd get bored. Drinking decaf might have the same taste, but when the liquid's gone, what are you left with?
I didn't really touch the stuff before I started living here in earnest. Mostly I just drank tea, and I still do, but I've since graduated to its stronger, younger sibling. I've come to appreciate the taste, but it still gets me so caffeinated that I get jittery. It becomes hard for me to focus on any single thing, and I opt instead for total sensory overload.
It's a mirror for my overall experience with this city. There are always so many possibilities, so many paths before me that at times it can be downright maddening. But whenever I try to imagine living anywhere else at this point in my life, I realize how quickly I'd get bored. Drinking decaf might have the same taste, but when the liquid's gone, what are you left with?
Monday, May 19, 2014
Titanfall: So You Want to Pilot Giant Robots Better
So Titanfall's pretty awesome. And they did something interesting with their prestige system. When you've hit the maximum level and want to start over so you can do it all again, it's presented in-universe as your cybernetically enhanced pilot opting to get "regenerated", which means a brand spanking new body but none of their original memories from since they've showed up on the frontier.
The setting also features robot infantry known as "Spectres".
So last Saturday, after a wee bit too much alcohol, I took that idea and ran with it, resulting in this:
Recorded from Hammond Robotics' Sparta Regeneration Facility, Dr. Rick ------- Ranking Technician
Next. Good morning. Here for the regen right? Good good, let me see your file here. Service on Troy, Battle of Demeter...neat stuff. Ah, first time here. Okay, gotta give you the spiel. If you'll walk this way...
Tuesday, May 13, 2014
World Building, Characters, Reservoir Dogs, and Lunch
The quickest way to get me uninterested in a story is by opening it with an expository monologue. Controversial statement, I know. But it's something I bring up because it's still a very important point to reiterate, because too often - especially in works of fantasy or science fiction - the person telling the story feels the need to front-end a bunch of maps, important dates, and a general overview of the history of the kingdom/colony/intergalactic empire.
And I kind of get the appeal of this "history textbook" approach to world-building. If it's good enough for Tolkien, it's good enough for you, right?
Wrong. People have been aping Tolkien for years now and quite frankly I'm sick of it. So here's what you should do instead of opening your book with a glossary of terms and technologies you'll only define this once or your movie with (God help you) a character giving an overwrought voice-over explaining why dragons are so important or how magic works in this particular universe: Have your characters go to lunch. This is how you get in your world-building and introduce your characters to the audience in one fell swoop.
Monday, January 27, 2014
The SCP Foundation and Me: A Case Study in Obsession
When it comes to well done and groundbreaking entertainment in new media, you won't find a better example than The SCP Foundation. The site is presented as the archives of an organization devoted to finding, containing, researching -and if necessary, destroying- anything deemed abnormally dangerous or harmful to humanity's perception of reality. This can range from a homicidal lizard that will never ever ever ever (ever) stay dead to a previously unknown integer that causes math to stop working to a green goo that mostly just smells minty but if it ever comes in contact with dead bodies something so terrible happens that most people aren't allowed to even know about it.
Most of the website is devoted to entries cataloguing these anomalous objects, although there are also a fair amount of stories dealing with the Foundation, the items it contains, and various other Groups of Interest that operate just outside of everyday life. The fact that the site is a wiki means that just about anyone can submit a piece, and there is a very active community involved in editing the site and reviewing new content. And I am
I started reading the site last year, but I didn't start binge reading until last summer, and since then I've eased into the habit of going to the site and just tabbing through the "random page" option whenever I'm procrastinating or just bored. So by now I'm intimately familiar with the site, but it's taken me that long to get there because this thing is huge. You could just chalk up my love for the Foundation to the fact that I'm a weird dude, but as I read more and more of the stuff on there I realized that my fondness for the site goes beyond mere entertainment value. There are three big themes that keep coming up throughout the site that I find rather compelling.
Friday, January 24, 2014
The Three Try to Steal All the Money, Ch. 3 Part 2
The next few
months saw Jastio participating in most of the pivotal battles that drove the
Insurrection of the Outer Territories to its conclusion. After Crown’s Reach the Citizen’s Militia
pushed through Pennsmouth and then Kathryn’s Bend. He saw action in both these
places, ranging from street to street fighting to house clearing to protracted
sniper engagements. Jastio fired his gun in every instance, and many times
killed someone too. More than once he was one of only two to survive a battle.
He received numerous commendations and received a pair of medals he almost
never wore. At war’s end his unit was positioned behind the regular army to
support their push against the final rebel stronghold in Crying Bluffs. He was
far from the battlefield when the surrender was made and the brutal civil war
ended. When the governor’s announcement of peace came over the radio his squad
cheered. Jastio might have joined in, he might not. He didn’t really remember
anymore.
The days after the
war all ran together. There was brief participation in military rule of the
outlying provinces before regular police forces could be re-established, and
not long after returning to the city he was honorably discharged. At the end of
his service, all he had to show for it was his rifle, his uniform, a pair of
medals, and the inability to get a decent night’s sleep. He didn’t even have
his own apartment, instead returning to live with his father just like before
his conscription. His life briefly seemed as though it was geared to return to
normal, the way it was before.
Wednesday, January 22, 2014
The Three Try to Steal All the Money, Ch. 3 Part 1
3: The Best Gunfighter in the World
On his fifty-sixth
day of service in the Kingsholm Citizen’s Militia, Jastio Finnegan killed his
first opponent. The suburb of Crown’s Reach had fallen to the rebels and his
unit had been tasked with uprooting them as the regular forces dealt with the
rebel’s main force to the east of the city. Twelve hours after occupying Finn
Square a sniper’s bullet pierced the helmet of the corporal, and the rest of
the squad found themselves crouching behind sandbags, statues, and signs for an
interminably long amount of time as another squad tried to pinpoint the
rifleman’s position. The only noise that pierced the tedium were distant
bird-calls, the muted thunder of far off artillery strikes, and a periodic
reverberating crack that signaled another
potshot from the sniper.
After a small
eternity the radio-man’s device crackled to life from his back, and the voice
on the other end told them where to look for their opponent. Pfc. McCluskey
took up position with his rifle as Jastio placed his helmet on a stick and
moved it just above the stonework of the fountain they were using as cover.
There was another crack, followed by a loud ping as the bullet ricocheted off
the helmet and directly into McCluskey’s chest. Jastio scrambled and moved to
put pressure on the wound, but McCluskey wasted no breath.
Monday, January 20, 2014
The Three Try to Steal All the Money, Ch. 2
2: The
Man with Too Many Names
As
the airship pushed off from Jiu Cliff, he checked his pocket watch, which
beeped 14:56 back at him. More than half an hour behind schedule, and if the
retrofitted propellers and giant seams in the fabric of the main balloon were
any indication the damned thing wouldn’t exactly be making good time. A liberal
estimate would place their time over Kao Tze at just before 16:00. That would
give Wei at least a full hour to wait around with no sign of the airship in the
sky. 60 minutes to realize that he probably had better things to do than wait
around with a land vehicle in the hopes of collecting a paltry sum that was
easily less than five percent of the score’s actual value. All he could do was
hope that he’d picked a driver with the right blend of enthusiastic and stupid
to let him pull this off.
As
the man reclined in his seat he made a show of reading his periodical while
going over the details one more time. His name today was Nigel Ingstrom III,
scion of a fuel magnate and his air-headed wife who was looking to find a place
for himself in the family business. This airship ride represented the
culmination of a grand tour of the Eastern Lands, scouting out prospects for
fuel sales in the region. His last stop had been the mining city of Bei Lan,
and while he could have hopped a train on the Central Line from there back home
to Kingsholm, even first class accommodations would pale in comparison to the
luxury afforded by an airship. And why would a man of such alleged stature as Mr.
Ingstrom ever settle for less?
Thursday, January 16, 2014
The Desert of Feedback
Whenever I talk with my friends in the working world one thing keeps coming up again and again. They're all like me, fresh out of college and new to the professional world, and they're all experiencing culture shock in the same way. It's not going from a couple of hours of classes a day to an eight-hour daily schedule and it isn't the different nature of the work they're doing. Psychologically we've all long since acknowledged that these will be major differences we're just going to have to get used to after making the transition out of school. The big sticking point, the one area where they haven't been as able to easily adjust, is the lack of feedback.
This is something I'd realized a while ago but it was only yesterday that I burned through Daniel Pink's Flip, which so succinctly and accurately addresses the issue and gave me the title for this post. Section 12 is entirely about the idea that our generation is being asked to make a stark transition from a world of instantaneous feedback to one where performance reviews are something that traditionally happen just once every year. As Pink points out, our generation is one where we've grown up with video games that instantly give you a score to judge your performance, where sending a text is met with a prompt acknowledgement that the message was delivered and then read. Even in school grades are constantly meted out, offering a tangible metric of ability.
About a month ago I picked up Splinter Cell: Blacklist, and since then I've sunk more hours into it than I thought I would. It's a fun game to be sure, but beyond the interesting asymmetrical multiplayer and the satisfying nature of its stealth it offers something else that triggers the endorphins in my brain like you wouldn't believe. Every takedown, every objective completed, every secret path found, is met with a message at the bottom of the screen acknowledging your action and awarding you points towards one of three styles of play. On average you'll get probably ten to twenty of these messages a minute.
This feedback not only isn't present in the working world, it isn't present in most aspects of life. Learning about the electoral college is one of the best ways to become disenfranchised with the current system of selecting presidents. A lot of the dissatisfaction with Congress stems from the feeling that the concerns of regular citizens aren't being heard over the din of money being thrown around by huge lobbying firms and corporations. Senators and representatives are perceived as being disconnected from the rest of the country, and this lack of feedback has led to staggeringly low approval ratings, if not outright disenfranchisement with the whole endeavor.
People want to feel like they're having an impact. It doesn't necessarily have to feel like a positive one, so long as it feels like our actions have contributed something. All I'm doing when I get an achievement in a video game is affect a number, a gamerscore that no one but me cares about, and yet this is one of the most popular features of the last generation and it prompts me to play in ways I might not have otherwise considered. It's a way to look at all the games you've played at a glance and the things you've done in them, a more tangible sense of accomplishment.
As I see it, addressing this lack of feedback is one of the biggest challenges faced by my generation as it enters the "real world". It helps explain why gamification has found such widespread application and acceptance, since it seeks to rectify precisely this problem in areas as disparate as purchasing decisions and personal fitness. Doing so will accomplish more than offering a sense of constant and contrived satisfaction. Effective feedback can foster motivation for those doing well, and can offer insight into how those who are struggling can improve.
Tuesday, January 14, 2014
The Three Try to Steal All the Money, Chapter 1
1:
The Girl Who Couldn’t Sleep
When Renee Altka
turned five years old, she was no longer able to sleep.
It
didn’t occur exactly on her fifth birthday but rather sometime shortly
afterwards. The exact date was lost because at first she and her family
regarded it as little more than the insomnia brought on by hyperactivity that
afflicts every small child. When a week passed without Renee sleeping a wink
her parents took her to a doctor, and as far as he could tell she was just
suffering from regular old insomnia. He gave her family a mild sedative to help
her re-adjust to a regular sleep schedule and that seemed to work for everyone
except Renee.
Truth
be told, all the drugs did for Renee was make her loopier than usual. She would
swallow one of the little blue pills then lie in bed and stare at the ceiling
for the entire night, a routine that continued well after she ran out of pills.
Each morning she would watch the sunrise and at breakfast before school her
parents would ask her how she’d slept. She always told them she’d slept fine -
out as soon as her head hit the pillow – because it was far easier than telling
them the whole truth. Then her parents would ask Renee about her dreams, which
were always so vivid and colorful, and when Renee answered this question she
didn’t have to lie, at least not totally. Her dreams were always recounted with
exquisite detail because she still had those, and they were far livelier than
any of the dreams she’d had in the first five years of her life.
Rather than inhabiting the odd and varied
landscapes of her mind, the creatures and objects that Renee dreamed of would
occupy the space around her. A cat with three tails and the ability to speak
the language of the Easterners would curl up at the foot of her bed. A woman
with a fox for a head wearing an intricately decorated shawl would sing an
ethereal melody, accompanying herself for the harmonies. There would be a man
dressed in the same top hat and suit worn by the carnival barker at the town
refinery’s fair every year, but instead of encouraging people to pitch in for
the raffle he would simply laugh to himself while detaching and reattaching his
right arm. At first Renee was worried all these apparitions would wake up her
mother and father, but no matter how loud they were her parents never betrayed
any suspicion that they’d heard weird noises coming from her room. Every night a cavalcade of images and
creatures would parade through Renee’s room as she lay on the bed and watched
them go, occasionally throwing a pillow at them and watching as it sailed through
their incorporeal forms.
Aside
from the nights Renee’s life was otherwise perfectly normal. She went to
school, made friends, tried to talk to boys, and liked to read despite her town
being small enough and distant enough from the Central Line that books were
hard to come by. Rather than severely impairing her, her sleeplessness merely
imbued her with a slightly loopy air. Sometimes she’d be asked what time it was
and reply that her begonias were fine, thank you very much, before snapping
back to reality and checking a clock. Occasionally she’d get into the habit of
simply stopping in the middle of the street and staring off into space, but
this rarely lasted more than half a minute. As far as Renee was concerned,
being regarded as slightly weird was a small price to pay for being able to
function on no sleep at all.
One
day when she was sixteen, one of her classmates kissed her. Tommy wasn’t the
cutest kid in her year, but he wasn’t half-bad looking, and he seemed nice
enough to boot. This all would have been fine if the kiss hadn’t happened
immediately after lunch with about half the school watching, and even that
would have been bearable if Tommy hadn’t followed the kiss by wheeling around
and yelling, “Dave, you owe me two coins! I kissed the crazy girl! Pay up!”
After
suffering through the rest of school, Renee didn’t go with her friends to The
Fountain for sweet drinks like they usually did. She also didn’t run home to
bawl her eyes out into her pillow. For reasons she couldn’t entirely explain,
Renee somehow found herself on Sentinel Hill overlooking the town. She took
shelter beneath the solitary tree that was the hill’s namesake, planted after
the guard tower that used to reside there was torn down some hundred years ago.
While the willow shaded her from the afternoon sun Renee reflected on the town
below. The tiny town, home to around five hundred people living in the shadow
of the Carlson Slime Refinery where her father and half the other fathers in
town worked, and whose newer generations would forever regard her as the crazy
one. No matter what work she took on or what passions she pursued, her unique
condition ensured that her title among the denizens of Carlson’s Landing would
be Renee the Crazy Girl who just wasn’t right in the head.
When
Renee did allow herself to cry, she felt something brushing up against her
cheek to wipe away the tears. The three-tailed cat purred and whispered
something to her she didn’t understand. She blinked, rubbed her eyes, and saw
the cat was still there, joined now by a baby-sized man in green pajamas
squatting in the grass nearby and producing cans of beans from his pockets. Renee
considered this for a moment as she scratched the cat behind its ears, then
stopped and realized what she was doing. The cat looked up at her, its eyes
almost as wide as hers, and meowed, “Jiaozi?”
Renee
dropped the cat and scrambled over to pick up one of the tiny cans of beans and
found that it rested comfortably in the palm of her hand. She threw it at the
tree and examined the chip of bark it knocked off the trunk. Renee smiled.
At
first she didn’t steal anything major. A cake or two from the bakery. Some
extra fried potatoes from another customer at The Fountain. Food was easiest
both because it was small enough and because the cat was her most willing
accomplice in this regard, at least once the language barrier was overcome and
she could assure him that he’d receive a portion of the profits. After a few
months Renee could even control which dreams manifested. Her friends grew more
distant as she spent less and less time with them, preferring to head from
school straight to Sentinel Hill. The stares and whispers she received in the
halls and streets didn’t matter as much to her anymore thanks to all the new
and interesting friends she could spring forth from her head.
A
couple years later when Tommy asked her to the final school dance it was
something of a surprise, and the giddiness it engendered was enough to keep her
aloft for the rest of the week. The joy and shock settled down the night of the
dance as the hours dragged on and Renee found herself sitting at her kitchen
table, waiting for a knock on the door and passing the time by playing cards
against the fox-headed woman. Rather than endure her parents returning to find
her sitting alone at home she stormed to the school and burst into the
gymnasium to find the dance in full swing.
She
brushed past her friends as they tried to speak to her and stormed over to
where Tommy was holding another girl in his arms right in front of the band. At
first he regarded her quizzically, but as memory kicked in a smile spread
across his face. At last he couldn’t help himself and burst out into laughter,
clearly amused by the idea that anyone would ever want to ask her to the dance.
He found himself joined by the chuckles and jeers of his friends nearby. Renee
couldn’t contain herself, but just as she was about to cry her head split open.
It was different from the dull aching pains which she’d grown well accustomed
to over the years. The sharp pain reverberated through her skull and as she
clutched her temples a tall man with no face and clad in a dark suit strode out
from the crowd and walked slowly but purposefully towards Tommy. The band
stopped playing and the entire crowd turned to see this man approach a now pale
Tommy and place a hand on his trembling shoulder.
Renee
redoubled her efforts and as she focused through the migraine the man in the
suit disappeared. The gym was silent as Renee collected herself, started to say
something, then thought better of it and made for the door. She took no chances
that night. Before her parents or anyone else could hear of what happened she
packed her things, grabbed what little money she’d saved in her sock drawer,
and ran off down the street. When she reached the top of Sentinel Hill she
stopped and regarded the small lights of Carlson’s Landing, hazy through the
smoke that rose from the slime fields. A bird with rainbow plumage flapped down
to perch on the tree branch above her and regarded her with its opal eye. When
it took flight again along the course of the Kraslow River, she followed it for
years.
Wednesday, December 18, 2013
Call of Duty: Ghosts ABRIDGED
Call of Duty: Ghosts was a game that initially aroused none of my interest. After five straight games in as many years, I was burned out on the franchise. But the more I heard about this latest iteration the more ridiculous it seemed. It couldn't really be that over the top and xenophobic, right? I mean most of the other COD games are less jingoistic than they appear on the surface, at least overtly. My curiosity ultimately got the better of me, and I decided to watch a play through of the game, both because the series really has gotten to the point where the player's presence is ancillary to the whole experience and because I couldn't find a copy to rent anywhere near me. What I saw confirmed that yes, actually, it's not just as bad as you might have heard, it's worse.
The result is what you see before you, with much apologies to The Editing Room.
CALL
OF DUTY: GHOSTS ABRIDGED
Friday, October 4, 2013
Update: XCOM is Kicking my Ass
The reason I don't watch much TV at all is because for me, video games are my TV. Instead of knocking out a few episodes whenever I have some downtime, I like to spend an hour or two playing a video game. It feels more active and there are plenty of games structured in episode-esque chunks. When I get a new game though I tend to play through the whole thing over the course of a weekend or two. Partially this is because most single player narratives are still structured like a movie or book and are more continuous, but it's also due to simply enjoying the novelty of a new experience.
About a week ago I bought XCOM: Enemy Unknown off the Xbox Live Marketplace since it was on sale. Yesterday instead of continuing my (sixth) campaign to save Earth from the alien scourge, I opted to replay another game. A simpler game. A less soul-crushing game.
Wednesday, September 18, 2013
Auteurs, Metal Gear Solid, and Dumb-Smart Games
But who cares about all that noise? I just finished the Metal Gear Solid HD collection on my Xbox so we're going to talk about that instead.
From hiimdaisy's "Let's Destroy the Shagohod!"
See, there are few things I feel as confused about as I do about Metal Gear Solid. I love to play it and talk about it despite the fact that I think pretty much every game in the series is deeply flawed.
Saturday, August 17, 2013
The Future Has Happened/Is Happening/Will Happen
This summer a few things happened to me that, though unconnected on their surface, have combined to produce a prolonged bout of introspection. Also, I don't have a job yet, so I just have too much time to think about this stuff.
The things that happened are:
1) I graduated college,
2) I engaged in a very heated discussion alongside a classmate of mine against my mom and a couple of her friends, and
3) I re-played Deus Ex: Human Revolution.
The first one is pretty self-explanatory, as there has been no shortage of puff pieces in numerous publications about how simply being a part of my generation means that I'm an entitled and ineffective burden on society, which is not exactly the way to boost the confidence of a new generation eager to enter the real world and start contributing to it.
The second thing was a bit more complicated, and lasted pretty much for the entire dinner. But I'll try and break it down here. Essentially, my mom and her friends (who were about her age) were arguing with me and a classmate of mine from high school who's just a couple years younger than me. The debate revolved around the older people's conception that our generation has, on the whole, less meaningful relationships and ways of communicating, due in large part to technology. We tried to counter with arguments like "technological change has always happened and has always shook up culture, like the printing press" and similar stuff but by the end of it we seemed no closer to convincing them. What's more I had a similar conversation around the same time between my grandparents and my best friend and I. I got the sense from both of these conversations that the older people felt the changes being wrought by our generation's use of social media and other such technologies was unprecedented for the changes being wrought upon our social landscape, and what's more such changes were unquestionably terrible overall in their effect on our development and lives.
And the third thing up there perfectly encapsulates where I was coming from in those debates (it helps that I was in the middle of my playthrough when that conversation happened). Deus Ex: Human Revolution is a game not just set in the future, but about the future, much like the way Far Cry 2 handles war. But where Far Cry 2 had a very definite message about war, Deus Ex's element of personal choice allows it to do more than just deliver one message, or even multiple messages. Deus Ex basically puts you into a very well-crafted world with its own political problems and actors and lets you decide how to respond.
In 2027, human cybernetic augmentation has become widespread, basically just this side of mass commercialization. The consequences of this development are widespread and manifold. On the one side are advocates of the technology who see it as the next step in human evolution. Embracing technological change on this scale is not just necessary for our development as a species, but is in essence our destiny, the culmination of hundreds of years of scientific progress. On the other hand, there are many who fear the dangers human augmentation can bring with it. Granting unnatural strength and abilities to everyone unchecked may do little more than usher in a Hobbesian nightmare of constant war, all against all, where the richest citizens who can afford the technology and drugs necessary to sustain its use can triumph over the lower classes, presuming they don't just chuck cars at them in an effort to be done with the whole thing more quickly. And then there are those in the shadows who see a future in the technology, albeit one carefully structured and controlled according to what they perceive as humanity's best interests.
Deus Ex exposes you to these viewpoints by placing you into a world where they already exist and letting you explore. As you read e-mails, books, and digital newspapers and overhear conversations by people on the street (not to mention occasionally getting involved in their problems), you manage to get a sense of where proponents of every argument are coming from. On the one hand, your boss David Sarif, head of a leading producer of augmentations, is adamant about the good this technology can do in the world and the opportunity it offers humanity as a species to transcend its mere physicality. On the other hand, he engages in shady practices all the time, occasionally asking you to join in as he displays a stark mentality of the ends justifying the means. Bill Taggart, the head of the anti-augmentation lobby, has supporters who are so extreme that they frequently resort to terrorism in opposition to the spread of this new technology. But then you get on his PC and read an e-mail from a woman about how his book and message managed to help her turn her life around and get back on track after a bout of suicidal depression.
At its core, the story and world of Human Revolution is about the societal tensions that arise when progress occurs, which is to say all the time. Change is never neat and never wholly bad or good. It is messy and different, and those are about the only constant things one can say about the process. And frankly, I feel that message rings a lot more true than "things now suck because they were just better back in my day". But what elevates the game is that it does give you the option to reject this progress. Choice is an integral part of the game, from how you talk to people to how lethally you want to approach situations. The view the game has of the central issue isn't made explicitly clear, and the player is left to draw their own conclusions. If Deus Ex does have one singular message, it's "Be Adaptable", which is made very clear by the last level of the game, which represents a stark change in gameplay from the entire rest of the game. If you've been dead-set on one particular playstyle for the whole game, you will be thrown for a loop for the last hour or so.
It's not like what I'm experiencing now is anything new. Generational debates have happened pretty much ever since there was more than one generation around. As Grampa Simpson said "I used to be 'with it'. But then they changed what 'it' was. Now what I'm 'with' isn't 'it' and what's 'it' seems weird and scary to me...it'll happen to you." But this divide has never been more apparent than right about now, as technological developments occur in such rapid succession that generational divides are not only deeper than they've ever been, but can occur even more frequently. And games like Deus Ex offer an interesting and constructive lens with which to approach these sorts of discussions. On the one hand, we can yell at each other until we're blue in the face about the precise value of Twitter to society at large. Or we could realize that change isn't necessarily good or bad. It simply is, and always has been. It shouldn't be demonized or glorified outright, but recognized as a constant which must be approached with a measured and calm mind.
A measured and calm mind that can invent arm-blades you can use to pull off sweet takedowns.
Monday, June 24, 2013
The Man of Steel, Not Of Tomorrow
(THERE ARE TOTALLY SPOILERS FOR MAN OF STEEL IN HERE)
If you look over the last few posts in this blog reaching all the way back to September, you'll notice a couple of themes which sort of overlap. They're basically:
A) People are hungry for (and are producing) new and interesting takes on old stories, probably due to the absolutely bonkers amount of media available in modern life.
B) Many big budget movies and games of a genre that frequently paint the protagonist (and the player) as a shining beacon of heroism have started to question that role. See: DMZ, Zero Dark Thirty, Spec Ops: The Line.
It's pretty obvious how these themes can overlap, and together they add up to a lot of media that are primarily concerned with deconstructing whatever it is they're depicting. This means critically examining aspects or tropes of a work that people usually take for granted and trying to apply them to something more closely resembling reality. The result usually is not-strictly speaking-fun, though when done well it can be quite engaging. In some cases it can even perform a necessary function, as when Spec Ops managed to make a lot of video game players and creators realize that maybe making games where the central mechanic is shooting people in the head as realistically as possible isn't the best way to depict heroism.
As far as comics go, the gold standard for deconstruction was Watchmen. It presented an alternate universe where superheroes exist as a fact of life, eventually being outlawed as vigilantes, and these heroes were in turn depicted as people who turned to that life due to ridiculously messed-up personalities. The comic also featured Dr. Manhattan (the blue guy in the picture up there), the only character in this altered history with actual superpowers. He's depicted as a god in the story, and his mere existence is enough to tip the scales of the Cold War in the 80s much farther than they ever went in real life. A character in the book remarks, "The superman exists, and he's American." Later he admits that this statement was altered from its original content, with "superman" standing in for his original phrasing, "God".
So, Man of Steel.
Sunday, May 12, 2013
Why Old Spice Wins at Marketing
If you are reading this blog, then you have seen this ad. That is just a statistical fact, and ordinarily I don't trust math, because it's performed by people who are interested in math, and therefore clearly have something deeply, intensely wrong with their brains. Those people should go see a brain doctor at once.
Anyway, that ad. It was just the first of many. It showed up 3 years ago and blew everyone away to such an extent that they're still going strong. All of these ads feature ridiculous effects and sharp writing that serve to get one message across clear as day: Use Old Spice and you will be the manliest of men. And we, the makers of Old Spice, know this.
It's that second part that is key to the success of Old Spice's marketing. Most other ads that take this tack, both before and after the revelation that was "The Man Your Man Could Smell Like", have tried to use the first part to varying effect. As an example, I would offer up every ad for pickup trucks ever made. It's a truism of advertising that you aren't just selling a product, you're selling an idea. When people make a decision to buy something they consider the act a sort of personal statement, and brands naturally recognize this. This is why successful marketing manages to tap into feelings that can transcend the obvious trappings of the product being sold. I don't watch sports, let alone soccer, but Nike has made tons of commercials centered around the game that I consider among my favorites of all time. This isn't just because of their impressive production values or the novel concepts they have as their premises. It's because they realize that soccer can be about so much more than just kicking a ball around a field. The ads are really about things like success being earned and not just granted, or how at the end of the day, our future is ours to determine.
Most ads, of course, aren't quite so high minded. Selling pick up trucks requires an emphasis on the fact that this truck is going to make you strong and powerful because it is big. That's about it. When they have done something similar to those Nike ads, they're still about how tough the people who buy (and make) these trucks are. Take a good long look at that commercial. It's selling an idealized vision of a lifestyle that has become marginalized in real life by agribusiness and gigantic factory farms, but the vision of a hardscrabble, salt of the earth farmer is so ingrained in the popular subconscious that the commercial can effectively use it as a shorthand for manliness, which they then link to the truck. The message is clear: buy a Ram pickup, and you will be as rough and tough as these grainy pictures we're flashing across the screen.
Old Spice, on the other hand, realizes there are more and more people becoming more aware of the tricks of the trade of marketing. The solution to this conundrum isn't self-deprecation: people aren't going to buy something if you tell them it's crap, because you're making it, so you would know better than anyone. The solution, rather, is to go in the exact opposite direction as hard as you can. Underlying all of the Old Spice commercials is the tacit acknowledgement that yes, the idea that a body spray can grant you the physique of a god is ridiculous. But that idea is also so hilarious that it becomes ripe for parody in a cavalcade of outrageous and hilarious commercials.
Old Spice ads don't just grab people's attention through their overload of images and crazy concepts. They speak to a self-awareness that is permeating a lot of the media that absolutely saturates our culture. Their philosophy is to take the implicit claims of other "manly" marketing campaigns and make them explicit, which manages to both defuse and win the argument at the same time. Ram can't claim with a straight face that buying one of their trucks will imbue you with the spirit of centuries of wizened cattle ranchers, but they can very heavily imply it. Old Spice explicitly says that using their body spray will enable you to win all the first place medals and live forever through your line of premium table crackers. My roommate once noted that a lot of commercials are just weird from an objective standpoint, because they're set in a world where the product being advertised is the most important thing in the life of the characters involved. Having bad teeth in a commercial for toothpaste is basically asking to be thrown in jail for making children everywhere burst into tears every time you open your ugly mouth. Old Spice takes this to its logical conclusion by making the men who use it in commercials into mythical heroes who can turn tickets into diamonds because they smell so good.
You just can't beat that. Being ridiculous on that same level for your product won't really work, because Old Spice already did that (and did it pretty much perfectly), and most other traditional ads pale in comparison. The Old Spice ads are brilliant because they manage to be almost perfect satires of a lot of other commercials, and even if you don't catch on to this, they still work because they're so well made and written. Old Spice has managed to both deconstruct and reconstruct the idea of marketing products as "manly", a feat that could obviously be accomplished only by a man who smells like freshly cut wood being used to build a boat for conquering the deadliest ocean.
Okay, I lied. Dos Equis does it well, too. You know what, forget everything I just wrote up there. The key to selling products is a deep voice. Get a dude with a deep, powerful voice, and everyone will buy whatever you're selling. There, done. Marketing: Solved. You're welcome, New York.
Saturday, April 27, 2013
This Is What War Looks Like
Zero Dark Thirty was criticized for tacitly glorifying torture. There's an argument that the film's presentation of the act being performed by the protagonist and other supporting characters on her side in the service of the search for Osama Bin Laden ultimately paints a more forgiving picture of the use of "enhanced interrogation" techniques. They might not be 100 percent reliable, but they get results, and at the end of the day they led to a successful raid against a mass murderer, a fact every audience is very aware of as they take their seats.
This is true.
The reply to this argument could be phrased as: while torture was used and some intelligence was gained from it, the film takes great pains to show these practices in unflinching detail. The viewer isn't meant to come around to a position of supporting the use of these methods, but they are necessary for understanding the full history of the war on terror and the search for bin Laden. They are there not in the service of propaganda, but rather of cinema verite, further reinforced by the documentary style in which the film is shot.
This is also true.
******
The Nazis and Japanese soldiers of World War II era action and adventure films, both contemporary works and more modern ones, are basically an amorphous blob of clones. They talk funny and all dress the same, and history has vindicated the wickedness of their cause, so go ahead and shoot about eleventy billion of them to prove how awesome you, the hero, are in the face of overwhelming odds. It's no surprise that some of the first video games to feature the player shooting humans and not aliens or demons saw Nazis as the targets. The National Socialist party was one of the most evil movements of the 20th century, and the conflict in question really did see scores of men charging at each other across fields and down bombed-out city streets. These images and the soldiers like Audie Murphy that spawned them were canonized as modern day warrior-saints, and subsequently elevated to the position of epic heroes like Hercules or Odysseus.
World War II has provided so many irresistible images that it has become the template of choice for politicians to use when arguing for war. Appeasement at Munich was the example provided to urge action in Vietnam and Iraq. After all, the Greatest Generation proved themselves in war, why can't we? I mean, if we couldn't, then how could we be Great, right?
*****
Nukes and TV (then later the internet) have ensured that we don't get to have our own World War II. The threat of mutually assured destruction from total war is too great to allow for that kind of conflict, first of all. But just as importantly, the world has shrunk. It's hard -not impossible, but still very hard- to label entire swathes of the world as vicious and savage when you can find out about what they're really like relatively easily. It's even harder to do this when you're supposed to be the good guys because you beat the bad guys who did just that in order to justify genocide on a previously unheard of scale.
9/11 was an evil act that killed thousands of innocents, but it wasn't perpetrated by a singular nation state, or even one definitive group of people. The perpetrators might be more accurately likened to a cult, both in their devotion to a warped creed and the manner in which they operate. But who's going to pay billions of dollars to mobilize the American war machine to go to war with a cult? And just as important, are you really going to sell what happened to the American people as the actions of a relatively small and messed up portion of the Earth's population? Will that be enough to rile them up in the face of this overwhelming attack? No, you're going to need a force of pure evil, formless but deadly. The problem, of course, is that they happen to look just like regular people. That, in fact, is a key component of their strategy.
We can wage war on armies quite well, better than anyone else in fact. But how the hell do you fight a war against people?
*****
The first scene of Zero Dark Thirty occurs over a black screen as audio from phone calls and radio dispatches culled from the events of September 11, 2001 play. The image of the towers on fire has been overused to the point of banality. Just over a decade out, it's hard for most people to feel much more than odd pangs of reminiscence when they see it. This audio, however, is not only fresh but effective. It's a singularly terrible human experience diluted to its essence, and accomplishes in just a minute or so what no bloated montage could hope to. Immediately after this, we cut to a scene of the main characters torturing a man. Not even a terrorist, but a middle man who handled finances for other terrorists. There is no soundtrack and the loud echoing of the interrogator's harsh commands all lend the scene a brutal immediacy. We can't help but sympathize for the captive, despite the fact that he helped murder 3000 innocent people, as the interrogator is quick to point out.
We don't know how to feel, and that's really the point. The truth is that the war on terror is such a complex mess of morally gray areas that there is no narrative that neatly fits it. In some cases, America kind of is the evil empire taking on the underdog rebels, which is supposed to make us the bad guys. In many others, we are the battered but still standing bastion of freedom staring down a violent fanaticism. We can be both and neither at the same time because the truth is there aren't ever just good guys and bad guys. At the end of the day, we're all just guys. And girls, fine, but you get the point.
*****
Commander Vimes, head of the Ankh-Morpork City Watch from Terry Pratchett's Discworld, is a great cop not just because he's diligent about enforcing the law, but because he's willing to ask himself if the law is worth enforcing. When his hometown is all set to be embroiled in a war with a far away, vaguely Middle-Eastern country, he at last manages to do the only sensible action available and moves to arrest both of the armies for attempting to commit the greatest crime of all; starting a war.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


















